Critique Request Just finished

[yakob]

Hi

I just finished it, I really want to hear your comments

Best Regards

 

[mdengraver]

Awesome! Love the composition!

 

[Willem Parel]

Very very nice those uniform scrolls.

 

[Red Green]

I'm assuming this is not a traditional scroll style, it may be but I've never seen it. The composition looks great, strong, down to earth and focused.

Bob

 

[Gun Nut]

Very nice. Great looking duck.

 

[golden forge]

Iv'e looked at it three times now, and yup, still drooling..... very nice indeed.

 

[Gemsetterchris]

Looks very very nicely cut, but somehow it gives me abit of a headache looking at it.
Maybe abit too uniform & those 2 lots of 4 big scrolls in the centre area somehow bother my eyes.
Just my personal opinion..

 

[Neo Dutch]

I like the little bit of white between the leaves.

 

[GTJC460]

It's very good. I like your scroll and the cutting is very clean.

I think the background behind the duck needs some work. You've got the nice engraving of the water and the duck. The sky/background just looks too plain. Some sky elements would really bring it all together as a scene.

Also maybe burnish in some bright spots in the water to give the appearance of reflections on the water.

 

[ETHELBERT]

I like it a bunch, the duck the scroll work, and I like the composition of the water and the cattails. I really like how the water looks.....great job

 

[jacoby pascal]

manque vraiment de paysage tu sais.

 

[karamundi]

great job I love