Critique Request Concho

[Luckyseven]

This is a 2" concho I just finished. Any critique would be great, go easy I'm pretty new! Sorry about the poor picture, any help there too.

Thanks
Ty

 

[ken dixon]

It looks like you are off to a good start. Just keep on cutting.

Ken

 

[Beathard]

Looks good to me.

 

[Robert Jobe]

Looks great. Good bright cuts.

 

[monk]

a great look here. but you asked for abuse-- here tizz : i would have made the scrolls mirror imaged. this would lend symmetry to an otherwise beautiful piece. you say you're pretty new-- well you're doing very well, i must say. your cutting is very good for "pretty new".

 

[Haraga.com]

Monk. Mirror images may not be the best choice.

 

[Brian Marshall]

Yep, I happen to agree with Captain Leonard. (of the newly christened "Scroll Police")

For this particular kind of work and where it will be seen - mirror image would not look "right"...



Brin

 

[Denny]

The cutting is quite good. Concerning design, you have quite a few flowers in this design. I believe that flowers look best as a more limited accent to the scroll work in western bright cut. In my humble opinion you have too many flowers in the design. Good luck and all the best to you on your engraving journey.

 

[Luckyseven]

Thanks for the advice and compliments!

Ty