I do not think Marcus or anyone else here was being intentionally unkind. Marcus simply hit the nail on the head, giving good advice.
I have learned since posting here that the written word is often if not always misconstrued from its intent by some, myself included. Forums are not the best means of communicating; however it is what we have to work with. Forums and writing are also a “learning†process.
The goal of becoming a “master†engraver is commendable…and learning engraving in the “self taught†manner while somewhat frowned upon by the general consensus it seems…is also not a bad thing. However there must be rime and reason to teaching oneself.
Simply put, if you (anyone) are adamant about teaching yourself,
……… don’t put the cart before the horse!
The following was posted yesterday on the “other forumâ€.
Ok, here are some words for your consideration.
What you are trying to accomplish with this plate to put bluntly, is beyond your current skill level. You are frustrating yourself and quite needlessly.
Start with the basics, TOOL CONTROL.
Layout straight lines of varying length-- cut to differing depths using assorted gravers. Practice cutting these until the straight line is mastered. Proceed to squares, rectangles etc. Once these cuts are mastered proceed to circles, ovals, simple scroll “back bone†layouts (no leaves). Cut the above until you can do all of them in your sleep with any graver you happen to pick up from your bench, even a dull one.
Once the basics are mastered then and only then proceed to “scroll pattern†practice.
While doing the above, continue with drawing/designing as it pertains to engraving. Collect as many books as possible that contain the styles/types of engraving you wish to become proficient at. Study both with as much diligence or more so as you give to your cutting practice.
j.c.
I have learned since posting here that the written word is often if not always misconstrued from its intent by some, myself included. Forums are not the best means of communicating; however it is what we have to work with. Forums and writing are also a “learning†process.
The goal of becoming a “master†engraver is commendable…and learning engraving in the “self taught†manner while somewhat frowned upon by the general consensus it seems…is also not a bad thing. However there must be rime and reason to teaching oneself.
Simply put, if you (anyone) are adamant about teaching yourself,
……… don’t put the cart before the horse!
The following was posted yesterday on the “other forumâ€.
“Help me become a Master Engraverâ€
Ok, here are some words for your consideration.
What you are trying to accomplish with this plate to put bluntly, is beyond your current skill level. You are frustrating yourself and quite needlessly.
Start with the basics, TOOL CONTROL.
Layout straight lines of varying length-- cut to differing depths using assorted gravers. Practice cutting these until the straight line is mastered. Proceed to squares, rectangles etc. Once these cuts are mastered proceed to circles, ovals, simple scroll “back bone†layouts (no leaves). Cut the above until you can do all of them in your sleep with any graver you happen to pick up from your bench, even a dull one.
Once the basics are mastered then and only then proceed to “scroll pattern†practice.
While doing the above, continue with drawing/designing as it pertains to engraving. Collect as many books as possible that contain the styles/types of engraving you wish to become proficient at. Study both with as much diligence or more so as you give to your cutting practice.
j.c.