General comments: I think that being a professional anything has more to do with attitude than anything else. Of course there are other important criteria. It is such a general guestion however, it is difficult to answer except generally, but it is not a matter of opinion. Rather, it is a conforming to certain eternal standards that will survive time, one being sound foundational structure,(the basic strength of your creation) Accuracy of interpretation, not human experience and perception (possible flawed evaluation), or reality. "Opinions" are often tainted by egos and/or selfish motive. Truth is not, so those with the attitude of the constant desire to meet those certain acurate standards are professionals, regardless of where you are in your skill level at this point in time.... As you begin to take steps on this path your skill and your evaluation tends to be relative to the environment in which you inhabit. General public (ignorance), educated observers ( patrons, students, and coneseurs of engraving) and then collectors (heavy investors). Both engraver's and consumer's sense of judgment changes with each catagory that you enter into.But don't be dismayed by this, because you are in the right environment for good progression. Be proud of your hard earned achievements, because it is in the struggle, not in the end result so much. Our simple desire for beauty and quality are the root determinators. I think you all have the right attitudes or you wouldn't be here. To me you are all professionals.................But that doesn't rule out the basic criteria for "good" work. To sum it up in one word. Accuracy: Acuracy in foundational structure. Accuracy in interpretation, and accuracy in skill. It takes those three elements to meet the basic requirements of good work, but there are two other valuable elements. Visual and emotional appeal. This is the trickster. If you can meet the criteria of these elements, your work will probably be a success in any circles, to some degree. I always heard too that if you can look back on your past efforts and find it pleasing rather than embarrasing, feel good and go forward..............If people are willing to pay you for it, don't give it away. That cheapens us all. You are worth whatever energy you have expelled to get to your level. The rest will sort of take care of itself if you are patient, tenacious, determined, and committed. Success is nothing but a series of failures anyway, on the way to wherever you are going. So is being thought of by others as professional so very important? I never thought it was. There just wasn't anything going to stop me on my path and I would move into that catagory by evolution. That is probably the way you will do it too.
Ron S
Ron S