Critique Request English Fine Scroll, fourth attempt

PÃ¤r BjÃ¶rkman · Dec 12, 2016

My fourth attempt engraving English Fine Scroll after studying Marcus Hunts fantastic book

JJ Roberts · Dec 12, 2016

Par,Your off to a good start keep up the good work. :thumbsup:

J.J.

Crossbolt · Dec 12, 2016

I like your work; I think it is better than what I see on mid to low range English guns and many Continental copies.
In a couple of spots toward the "handle" end I see larger scrolls growing from small ones but that is a small detail and I shouldn't be one to comment as it is much nicer than anything I'm producing at the moment.

As an aside I'll agree on how fantastic Marcus's book and DVD are. I rewatch the DVD after practicing and each time pick up on details I'm missing ... even things he doesn't explicitly say but can be seen. I'll probably wear it out

Jeremy

John B. · Dec 12, 2016

Your engraving and the knife are great. Well done.
Please work a little harder and give a little more thought to the outside work on your next piece.
Your photography is outstanding, thank you for posting your pictures.

Critique Request English Fine Scroll, fourth attempt

PÃ¤r BjÃ¶rkman

Member

Attachments

JJ Roberts

:::Pledge Member:::

Crossbolt

Elite Cafe Member

John B.

Lifetime Pledge Member

Latest posts

Sponsors